Does God harm people? Does he beat up his kids? Does God
bring sickness, disease, even death, in order to accomplish good in his kids?
One verse that people use to support this theological drivel is Hebrews 12:6, which reads (in the NKJV):
One verse that people use to support this theological drivel is Hebrews 12:6, which reads (in the NKJV):
For whom the LORD loves He
chastens, And scourges every son whom He receives."
A quick glance at a Greek lexicon will help us.
The Greek word used for “chasten” is παιδεύω. The Strongs lexicon (http://bit.ly/TbnnDR) says the primary meaning of παιδεύω is:
1) to train children
a) to be instructed or taught or learn
b) to cause one to learn
Since the immediate context is about fathers training their children, and specifically compares God’s fathering to human fathering, this is an excellent contextual fit. The idea is more of a firm coach than a child-abuser, and the context, very much about fathering, supports the concept of instructing, training, coaching.
The Greek word used for “chasten” is παιδεύω. The Strongs lexicon (http://bit.ly/TbnnDR) says the primary meaning of παιδεύω is:
1) to train children
a) to be instructed or taught or learn
b) to cause one to learn
Since the immediate context is about fathers training their children, and specifically compares God’s fathering to human fathering, this is an excellent contextual fit. The idea is more of a firm coach than a child-abuser, and the context, very much about fathering, supports the concept of instructing, training, coaching.
By contrast, when was the last time you heard of a father
that brought home a polio virus to infect his son as an expression of his love?
What loving dad would cut his daughter’s brake lines so she’d crash and spend a month
in ICU? Who in their right mind would respect such a father or hold him up as
an example for others to follow? [Hint: it wouldn’t be God!]
Does he train us hard? Well, when was the last time that a
competent coach who trained his players gently? Did they every win anything?
Sure, training is hard. But it is not abusive. It's not about sickness, death
and destruction; that's somebody else's job description. Jesus came that we
“may have life, and that they may have it more abundantly.” (Romans 10:10)
The second half of the verse is considered metaphor by Greek
language scholars, and it is in the Hebrew pattern of “parallelism”: the second
phrase complements or clarifies the first phrase: Yes, God trains his kids.
“For whom the Lord loves, he trains, and he spanks his sons when they need it.”
Parallel ideas: the first phrase tells us how to interpret the second phrase.
A better theological foundation about the nature of God is found earlier in Hebrews: in 1:3, the Bible declares, “The Son is the radiance of God's glory and the exact representation of his being.” Note: “Exact representation.”
A better theological foundation about the nature of God is found earlier in Hebrews: in 1:3, the Bible declares, “The Son is the radiance of God's glory and the exact representation of his being.” Note: “Exact representation.”
In other words: Whatever is true about God’s being is
demonstrated in Jesus. In other words, if you don’t see something in Jesus,
you’re in error if you believe it about God.
A lot of people have this OT image of God always ready to smite someone, always ready to judge people with death and disaster. That’s poppycock! How many people did Jesus smite? How many did he kill? How many times did someone come to Jesus, “the exact representation” of God’s being, asking to be healed, only to be told, “No, it’s better if you stay sick, because you’re learning something from the sickness.”
That, of course, is the theological equivalent of saying, “The devil – whose job it is to steal, kill and destroy – can do a better job of raising God’s kids through stealing killing and destroying, than God can do through loving them.” That, I’m afraid, is profitable for nothing more serious than fertilizing your tomatoes: run away from such stinky, libelous accusations of God’s character!
Someone will say (and often loudly and rudely): “But God judges sin! God is holy!”
A lot of people have this OT image of God always ready to smite someone, always ready to judge people with death and disaster. That’s poppycock! How many people did Jesus smite? How many did he kill? How many times did someone come to Jesus, “the exact representation” of God’s being, asking to be healed, only to be told, “No, it’s better if you stay sick, because you’re learning something from the sickness.”
That, of course, is the theological equivalent of saying, “The devil – whose job it is to steal, kill and destroy – can do a better job of raising God’s kids through stealing killing and destroying, than God can do through loving them.” That, I’m afraid, is profitable for nothing more serious than fertilizing your tomatoes: run away from such stinky, libelous accusations of God’s character!
Someone will say (and often loudly and rudely): “But God judges sin! God is holy!”
Yes, God is holy. And yes God judges sin; in fact he has
already judged sin: Jesus was judged for sin! He was crucified, nailed to a
tree, because of sin; because of all sin! In fact, “while we
were still sinners, Christ died for us.” (Romans 5:8)
So then, whose sins did Jesus miss? Whose sins are still
un-judged? Whose sin is too big for the sacrifice of the Incarnate Son of God?
Who did God overlook in his dying for the entire world? There ain’t none!
(Though you and I know that there are some folks that are working hard to reject his
payment for their sin; that’s a different conversation, and involves Revelation
20.)
Let’s acknowledge that God is actually good, and let’s
expect goodness from him.